Effects of pulp industry effluents: certainties and doubts

The growth pattern of the pulp and paper industry, as well as the associated forestry model, reveals a growing tendency to expand in Asia, Africa and South America. We believe that it is necessary to incorporate the environmental perspective on social consciousness so that decisions regarding the use and management of natural resources are not taken just by following the logic of the market. The concept of ecosystem services is a valuable aid in the analysis of environmental conflicts. The identification and quantification of ecosystem services is important because many times these services are not apparent to the average person or decision maker. In this article we focus on the analysis of the evidence of the direct impacts produced by the industrial effluents arising from the operation of pulp mills. These effluents have a considerable complexity due to the number of chemical compounds that they contain, some of them unidentified until now. Their effects are site-dependent where the physico-chemical characteristics of the receiver corp, its flow, the type of wood used in the industrial process, the effluent treatment adopted, as well as the sensitivity of the species in the ecosystem are some of the factors that determine the possible responses of the environment. Nevertheless, many ecotoxicological and eutrophication studies of water bodies have shown that some of the potential effects occur in different and distant biogeographic regions of the planet and regardless of the specific type of industrial process used. This work describe these effects, that are widely documented in the scientific literature, presented from the simplest levels of biological organization (molecular) to the most complex (ecosystems). In particular, the effects of the exposure to the endocrine disruptors have abundant laboratory and field evidence that have allowed to determine their mechanisms of action. The incorporation of new phases (e.g., secondary) in the treating systems of the industrial effluents mitigates the acute effects but not the chronic responses recorded. Based on the known effects we consider the potential impacts on the ecosystem functions and the main challenges for Latin America in the planning of this productive activity. Finally, we mention the existing difficulties in addressing environmental problems such as the high levels of associated uncertainty, the complex nature of the responses of the systems to shock or stress and the information gaps. In this scenario, we believe that the independent academic input and analysis should contribute to the decision making and help the society to build a grounded opinion.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Altesor, Alice, Eguren, Gabriela, Mazzeo, Nestor, Panario, Daniel, Rodríguez, Claudia
Format: Digital revista
Language:spa
Published: Asociación Argentina de Ecología 2008
Online Access:https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1376
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id rev-ecoaus-article-1376
record_format ojs
institution AUSTRAL
collection OJS
country Argentina
countrycode AR
component Revista
access En linea
databasecode rev-ecoaus
tag revista
region America del Sur
libraryname Asociación Argentina de Ecología
language spa
format Digital
author Altesor, Alice
Eguren, Gabriela
Mazzeo, Nestor
Panario, Daniel
Rodríguez, Claudia
spellingShingle Altesor, Alice
Eguren, Gabriela
Mazzeo, Nestor
Panario, Daniel
Rodríguez, Claudia
Effects of pulp industry effluents: certainties and doubts
author_facet Altesor, Alice
Eguren, Gabriela
Mazzeo, Nestor
Panario, Daniel
Rodríguez, Claudia
author_sort Altesor, Alice
title Effects of pulp industry effluents: certainties and doubts
title_short Effects of pulp industry effluents: certainties and doubts
title_full Effects of pulp industry effluents: certainties and doubts
title_fullStr Effects of pulp industry effluents: certainties and doubts
title_full_unstemmed Effects of pulp industry effluents: certainties and doubts
title_sort effects of pulp industry effluents: certainties and doubts
description The growth pattern of the pulp and paper industry, as well as the associated forestry model, reveals a growing tendency to expand in Asia, Africa and South America. We believe that it is necessary to incorporate the environmental perspective on social consciousness so that decisions regarding the use and management of natural resources are not taken just by following the logic of the market. The concept of ecosystem services is a valuable aid in the analysis of environmental conflicts. The identification and quantification of ecosystem services is important because many times these services are not apparent to the average person or decision maker. In this article we focus on the analysis of the evidence of the direct impacts produced by the industrial effluents arising from the operation of pulp mills. These effluents have a considerable complexity due to the number of chemical compounds that they contain, some of them unidentified until now. Their effects are site-dependent where the physico-chemical characteristics of the receiver corp, its flow, the type of wood used in the industrial process, the effluent treatment adopted, as well as the sensitivity of the species in the ecosystem are some of the factors that determine the possible responses of the environment. Nevertheless, many ecotoxicological and eutrophication studies of water bodies have shown that some of the potential effects occur in different and distant biogeographic regions of the planet and regardless of the specific type of industrial process used. This work describe these effects, that are widely documented in the scientific literature, presented from the simplest levels of biological organization (molecular) to the most complex (ecosystems). In particular, the effects of the exposure to the endocrine disruptors have abundant laboratory and field evidence that have allowed to determine their mechanisms of action. The incorporation of new phases (e.g., secondary) in the treating systems of the industrial effluents mitigates the acute effects but not the chronic responses recorded. Based on the known effects we consider the potential impacts on the ecosystem functions and the main challenges for Latin America in the planning of this productive activity. Finally, we mention the existing difficulties in addressing environmental problems such as the high levels of associated uncertainty, the complex nature of the responses of the systems to shock or stress and the information gaps. In this scenario, we believe that the independent academic input and analysis should contribute to the decision making and help the society to build a grounded opinion.
publisher Asociación Argentina de Ecología
publishDate 2008
url https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1376
work_keys_str_mv AT altesoralice effectsofpulpindustryeffluentscertaintiesanddoubts
AT egurengabriela effectsofpulpindustryeffluentscertaintiesanddoubts
AT mazzeonestor effectsofpulpindustryeffluentscertaintiesanddoubts
AT panariodaniel effectsofpulpindustryeffluentscertaintiesanddoubts
AT rodriguezclaudia effectsofpulpindustryeffluentscertaintiesanddoubts
AT altesoralice laindustriadelacelulosaysusefectoscertezaseincertidumbres
AT egurengabriela laindustriadelacelulosaysusefectoscertezaseincertidumbres
AT mazzeonestor laindustriadelacelulosaysusefectoscertezaseincertidumbres
AT panariodaniel laindustriadelacelulosaysusefectoscertezaseincertidumbres
AT rodriguezclaudia laindustriadelacelulosaysusefectoscertezaseincertidumbres
_version_ 1755912482243739648
spelling rev-ecoaus-article-13762020-11-04T17:52:05Z Effects of pulp industry effluents: certainties and doubts La industria de la celulosa y sus efectos: certezas e incertidumbres Altesor, Alice Eguren, Gabriela Mazzeo, Nestor Panario, Daniel Rodríguez, Claudia environmental conflict paper consumption endocrine disruptor ecotoxicology industrial effluents eutrophication kraft process ecosystem services conflicto ambiental consumo de papel disruptor endócrino ecotoxicología efluentes industriales eutrofización proceso kraft servicios ecosistémicos The growth pattern of the pulp and paper industry, as well as the associated forestry model, reveals a growing tendency to expand in Asia, Africa and South America. We believe that it is necessary to incorporate the environmental perspective on social consciousness so that decisions regarding the use and management of natural resources are not taken just by following the logic of the market. The concept of ecosystem services is a valuable aid in the analysis of environmental conflicts. The identification and quantification of ecosystem services is important because many times these services are not apparent to the average person or decision maker. In this article we focus on the analysis of the evidence of the direct impacts produced by the industrial effluents arising from the operation of pulp mills. These effluents have a considerable complexity due to the number of chemical compounds that they contain, some of them unidentified until now. Their effects are site-dependent where the physico-chemical characteristics of the receiver corp, its flow, the type of wood used in the industrial process, the effluent treatment adopted, as well as the sensitivity of the species in the ecosystem are some of the factors that determine the possible responses of the environment. Nevertheless, many ecotoxicological and eutrophication studies of water bodies have shown that some of the potential effects occur in different and distant biogeographic regions of the planet and regardless of the specific type of industrial process used. This work describe these effects, that are widely documented in the scientific literature, presented from the simplest levels of biological organization (molecular) to the most complex (ecosystems). In particular, the effects of the exposure to the endocrine disruptors have abundant laboratory and field evidence that have allowed to determine their mechanisms of action. The incorporation of new phases (e.g., secondary) in the treating systems of the industrial effluents mitigates the acute effects but not the chronic responses recorded. Based on the known effects we consider the potential impacts on the ecosystem functions and the main challenges for Latin America in the planning of this productive activity. Finally, we mention the existing difficulties in addressing environmental problems such as the high levels of associated uncertainty, the complex nature of the responses of the systems to shock or stress and the information gaps. In this scenario, we believe that the independent academic input and analysis should contribute to the decision making and help the society to build a grounded opinion. El patrón de crecimiento de la industria de la pulpa y del papel, así como del modelo forestal asociado, revela una tendencia creciente a expandirse en países de Asia, África y América del Sur. En este escenario es necesario incorporar la perspectiva ambiental en la conciencia social para que las decisiones de uso y manejo de los recursos naturales no sean tomadas siguiendo sólo la lógica del mercado, por lo cual el concepto de servicios ecosistémicos es una ayuda valiosa para el análisis de los conflictos ambientales. Este artículo analiza las evidencias de los impactos puntuales que producen los efluentes industriales derivados del funcionamiento de las plantas de celulosa. Estos efluentes presentan una considerable complejidad por la cantidad de compuestos químicos que contienen, algunos no identificados al día de hoy. Sus efectos dependen del sitio en el que ocurren, de las características físico-químicas del cuerpo receptor, de su caudal, del tipo de madera, del proceso industrial y del tratamiento de efluentes empleado y de la sensibilidad de las especies presentes en el ecosistema. Sin embargo, existen numerosos estudios ecotoxicológicos y sobre la eutrofización de cuerpos de agua que demuestran que algunos de los potenciales efectos ocurren en regiones diferentes y distantes e independientemente del tipo específico de proceso industrial empleado. Los efectos derivados de la exposición a disruptores endócrinos cuentan con abundantes evidencias de laboratorio y de campo que han permitido establecer sus mecanismos de acción. Además, si bien la incorporación de nuevas fases (e.g., la fase secundaria) a los sistemas de tratamiento de efluentes industriales mitiga los efectos agudos, no mitiga las respuestas crónicas registradas. En función de los efectos conocidos se consideran las posibles consecuencias sobre las funciones ecosistémicas, y cuáles son los principales desafíos de América Latina para planificar esta actividad productiva. Los grados elevados de incertidumbre asociados, el carácter complejo de las respuestas de los sistemas frente a las perturbaciones o al estrés, y los vacíos de información limitan nuestra capacidad para enfrentar los problemas ambientales. El análisis y el aporte académico libre de conflictos de intereses deben contribuir a la toma de decisiones y a que la sociedad construya una opinión fundamentada. Asociación Argentina de Ecología 2008-12-01 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1376 Ecología Austral; Vol. 18 No. 3 (2008); 291-303 Ecología Austral; Vol. 18 Núm. 3 (2008); 291-303 0327-5477 1667-7838 spa https://ojs.ecologiaaustral.com.ar/index.php/Ecologia_Austral/article/view/1376/742 Derechos de autor 2020 Ecología Austral