An alternative method for assessing the equivalence among treatments in survival analysis

This work aims to evaluate the use of parametric models instead of a nonparametric procedure to adjust survival curves related to different treatments, and to verify the equivalence among treatments by the multivariate method of cluster analysis. The dataset used to validate the method was obtained from a laboratory experiment with cutting ants. Eight colonies of cutting ants were used, each one receiving different treatments. The exponential, Weibull, log-normal, and logistic models were adjusted for each treatment, along with the usual Kaplan-Meier adjustment. The logistic model used was the best option for evaluating the survival of the ants. Therefore, this model was adjusted for each treatment. The estimates of the parameters of each adjusted model were clustered using Ward's method of multivariate technique of cluster analysis. Finally, heuristic techniques for choosing the number of clusters were applied in order to define the sets of equivalent treatments. For the dataset used, the proposed method was less laborious and as efficient as the logrank for the comparison of many survival curves.

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Peternelli,Luiz Alexandre, Tomaz,Flávia Sílvia Corrêa, Bernardes,Diego Paiva, Silva,Gilson Fernandes da, Lacerda,Fabricia Gonçalves
Format: Digital revista
Language:English
Published: Universidade Federal de Santa Maria 2013
Online Access:http://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0103-84782013000900004
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id oai:scielo:S0103-84782013000900004
record_format ojs
spelling oai:scielo:S0103-847820130009000042013-08-16An alternative method for assessing the equivalence among treatments in survival analysisPeternelli,Luiz AlexandreTomaz,Flávia Sílvia CorrêaBernardes,Diego PaivaSilva,Gilson Fernandes daLacerda,Fabricia Gonçalves logrank test cluster analysis curves comparison This work aims to evaluate the use of parametric models instead of a nonparametric procedure to adjust survival curves related to different treatments, and to verify the equivalence among treatments by the multivariate method of cluster analysis. The dataset used to validate the method was obtained from a laboratory experiment with cutting ants. Eight colonies of cutting ants were used, each one receiving different treatments. The exponential, Weibull, log-normal, and logistic models were adjusted for each treatment, along with the usual Kaplan-Meier adjustment. The logistic model used was the best option for evaluating the survival of the ants. Therefore, this model was adjusted for each treatment. The estimates of the parameters of each adjusted model were clustered using Ward's method of multivariate technique of cluster analysis. Finally, heuristic techniques for choosing the number of clusters were applied in order to define the sets of equivalent treatments. For the dataset used, the proposed method was less laborious and as efficient as the logrank for the comparison of many survival curves.info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessUniversidade Federal de Santa MariaCiência Rural v.43 n.9 20132013-09-01info:eu-repo/semantics/articletext/htmlhttp://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0103-84782013000900004en10.1590/S0103-84782013000900004
institution SCIELO
collection OJS
country Brasil
countrycode BR
component Revista
access En linea
databasecode rev-scielo-br
tag revista
region America del Sur
libraryname SciELO
language English
format Digital
author Peternelli,Luiz Alexandre
Tomaz,Flávia Sílvia Corrêa
Bernardes,Diego Paiva
Silva,Gilson Fernandes da
Lacerda,Fabricia Gonçalves
spellingShingle Peternelli,Luiz Alexandre
Tomaz,Flávia Sílvia Corrêa
Bernardes,Diego Paiva
Silva,Gilson Fernandes da
Lacerda,Fabricia Gonçalves
An alternative method for assessing the equivalence among treatments in survival analysis
author_facet Peternelli,Luiz Alexandre
Tomaz,Flávia Sílvia Corrêa
Bernardes,Diego Paiva
Silva,Gilson Fernandes da
Lacerda,Fabricia Gonçalves
author_sort Peternelli,Luiz Alexandre
title An alternative method for assessing the equivalence among treatments in survival analysis
title_short An alternative method for assessing the equivalence among treatments in survival analysis
title_full An alternative method for assessing the equivalence among treatments in survival analysis
title_fullStr An alternative method for assessing the equivalence among treatments in survival analysis
title_full_unstemmed An alternative method for assessing the equivalence among treatments in survival analysis
title_sort alternative method for assessing the equivalence among treatments in survival analysis
description This work aims to evaluate the use of parametric models instead of a nonparametric procedure to adjust survival curves related to different treatments, and to verify the equivalence among treatments by the multivariate method of cluster analysis. The dataset used to validate the method was obtained from a laboratory experiment with cutting ants. Eight colonies of cutting ants were used, each one receiving different treatments. The exponential, Weibull, log-normal, and logistic models were adjusted for each treatment, along with the usual Kaplan-Meier adjustment. The logistic model used was the best option for evaluating the survival of the ants. Therefore, this model was adjusted for each treatment. The estimates of the parameters of each adjusted model were clustered using Ward's method of multivariate technique of cluster analysis. Finally, heuristic techniques for choosing the number of clusters were applied in order to define the sets of equivalent treatments. For the dataset used, the proposed method was less laborious and as efficient as the logrank for the comparison of many survival curves.
publisher Universidade Federal de Santa Maria
publishDate 2013
url http://old.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0103-84782013000900004
work_keys_str_mv AT peternelliluizalexandre analternativemethodforassessingtheequivalenceamongtreatmentsinsurvivalanalysis
AT tomazflaviasilviacorrea analternativemethodforassessingtheequivalenceamongtreatmentsinsurvivalanalysis
AT bernardesdiegopaiva analternativemethodforassessingtheequivalenceamongtreatmentsinsurvivalanalysis
AT silvagilsonfernandesda analternativemethodforassessingtheequivalenceamongtreatmentsinsurvivalanalysis
AT lacerdafabriciagoncalves analternativemethodforassessingtheequivalenceamongtreatmentsinsurvivalanalysis
AT peternelliluizalexandre alternativemethodforassessingtheequivalenceamongtreatmentsinsurvivalanalysis
AT tomazflaviasilviacorrea alternativemethodforassessingtheequivalenceamongtreatmentsinsurvivalanalysis
AT bernardesdiegopaiva alternativemethodforassessingtheequivalenceamongtreatmentsinsurvivalanalysis
AT silvagilsonfernandesda alternativemethodforassessingtheequivalenceamongtreatmentsinsurvivalanalysis
AT lacerdafabriciagoncalves alternativemethodforassessingtheequivalenceamongtreatmentsinsurvivalanalysis
_version_ 1756406182604439552