A global synthesis reveals biodiversity-mediated benefits for crop production
Natural and modified ecosystems contribute a multitude of functions and services that support human well-being (1, 2). It has long been recognized that biodiversity plays an important role in the functioning of ecosystems (3, 4), but the dependence of ecosystem services on biodiversity is under debate. An early synthesis revealed inconsistent results (5), whereas subsequent studies suggest that a few dominant species may supply the majority of ecosystem services (6, 7). It thus remains unclear whether a few dominant or many complementary species are needed to supply ecosystem services. The interpretation of earlier studies has been controversial because multiple mechanisms underlying changes in ecosystem service response to biodiversity can operate in combination (8, 9). On one hand, communities with many species are likely to include species responsible for large community-wide effects due to statistical selection. On the other hand, such diverse communities may contain a particular combination of species that complement each other in service provisioning. While these mechanisms imply positive effects of species richness on ecosystem service supply, total organism abundance or dominance of certain species may also drive the number of interactions benefiting ecosystem service supply. Depending on the relative importance of species complementarity, community abundance, and the role of dominant species, different relationships between species richness and ecosystem services can be expected (10). In real-world ecosystems, natural communities consist of a few highly abundant (dominant species) and many rare ones. The importance of richness, abundance, and dominance is likely to be influenced by the extent to which relative abundance changes with species richness (11) and by differences in the effectiveness and degree of specialization of service-providing communities. However, these three aspects of diversity have typically been tested in isolation and mainly in small-scale experimental settings (12, 13), while a synthetic study contrasting their SCIENCE ADVANCES | RESEARCH ARTICLE Dainese et al., Sci. Adv. 2019;5: eaax0121 16 October 2019 1 of 13 on October 17, 2019 http://advances.sciencemag.org/ Downloaded from relative importance in real-world ecosystems is still lacking. A major limitation to resolving these relationships is a lack of evidence from real-world human-driven biodiversity changes (14, 15), particularly for ecosystem services in agroecosystems. For instance, changes in richness and total or relative abundance of service-providing organisms in response to land-clearing for agriculture (16, 17) could alter the flow of benefits to people in different ways compared to experimental random loss of biodiversity. Over the past half-century, the need to feed a growing world population has led to markedly expanded and intensified agricultural production, transforming many regions into simplified landscapes (18). This transformation not only has contributed to enhanced agricultural production but also has led to the degradation of the global environment. The loss of biodiversity can disrupt key intermediate services to agriculture, such as crop pollination (19) and biological pest control (20), which underpin the final provisioning service of crop production (21). The recent stagnation or even decline of crop yields with ongoing intensification (22) indicates that alternative pathways are necessary to maintain future stable and sustainable crop production (23–25). An improved understanding of global biodiversity-driven ecosystem services in agroecosystems and their cascading effects on crop production is urgently needed to forecast future supplies of ecosystem services and to pursue strategies for sustainable management (15). We compiled an extensive database comprising 89 studies that measured richness and abundance of pollinators, pest natural enemies, and associated ecosystem services at 1475 sampling locations around the world (Fig. 1A). We focused on the ecosystem services of pollination and biological pest control because these services are essential to crop production and have been the focus of much research in recent decades (26). We quantified pollinator and pest natural enemy richness as the number of unique taxa sampledfrom each location (field), abundance as the number of observed individuals, and evenness (or the complementary term
Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Journal Article biblioteca |
Language: | English |
Published: |
American Association for the Advancement of Science
2019-10-04
|
Subjects: | crop production, |
Online Access: | https://hdl.handle.net/10568/105463 https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aax0121 |
Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
id |
dig-cgspace-10568-105463 |
---|---|
record_format |
koha |
institution |
CGIAR |
collection |
DSpace |
country |
Francia |
countrycode |
FR |
component |
Bibliográfico |
access |
En linea |
databasecode |
dig-cgspace |
tag |
biblioteca |
region |
Europa del Oeste |
libraryname |
Biblioteca del CGIAR |
language |
English |
topic |
crop production crop production |
spellingShingle |
crop production crop production Dainese, Matteo Martin, Emily A. Aizen, Marcelo A. Albrecht, Matthias Bartomeus, Ignasi Bommarco, Riccardo Carvalheiro, Luísa G. Chaplin-Kramer, Rebecca Gagic, Vesna Garibaldi, Lucas A. Ghazoul, Jaboury Grab, Heather Jonsson, Mattias Karp, Daniel S. Kennedy, Christina M. Kleijn, David Kremen, Claire Lands, Douglas A. Letourneau, Deborah K. Marini, Lorenzo Poveda, Katja Rader, Romina Smith, Henrik G. Tscharntke, Teja Andersson, Georg K.S. Badenhausser, Isabelle Baensch, Svenja Bezerra, Antonio Diego M. Bianchi, Felix J.J.A. Boreux, Virginie Bretagnolle, Vincent Caballero López, Berta Cavigliasso, Pablo Ćetković, Aleksandar Chacoff, Natacha P. Classen, Alice Cusser, Sarah Silva e Silva, Felipe D. da Groot, G. Arjen de Dudenhöffer, Jan H. Ekroos, Johan Fijen, Thijs Franck, Pierre Freitas, Breno M. Garratt, Michael P.D. Gratton, Claudio Hipólito, Juliana Holzschuh, Andrea Hunt, Lauren Iverson, Aaron L. Jha, Shalene Keasar, Tamar Kim, Tania N. Kishinevsky, Miriam Klatt, Björn K. Klein, Alexandra-Maria Krewenka, Kristin M. Krishnan, Smitha Larsen, Ashley E. Lavigne, Claire Liere, Heidi Maas, Bea Mallinger, Rachel E. Martínez Pachon, Eliana Martínez Salinas, Alejandra Meehan, Timothy D. Mitchell, Matthew G.E. Molina, Gonzalo A.R. Nesper, Maike Nilsson, Lovisa O'Rourke, Megan E. Peters, Marcell K. Plećaš, Milan Potts, Simon G. Ramos, Davi de L. Rosenheim, Jay A. Rundlöf, Maj Rusch, Adrien Sáez, Agustín Scheper, Jeroen Schleuning, Matthias Schmack, Julia M. Sciligo, Amber R. Seymour, Colleen Stanley, Dara A. Stewart, Rebecca Stout, Jane C. Sutter, Louis Takada, Mayura B. Taki, Hisatomo Tamburini, Giovanni Tschumi, Matthias Viana, Blandina F. Westphal, Catrin Willcox, Bryony K. Wratten, Stephen D. Yoshioka, Akira Zaragoza-Trello, Carlos Wei Zhang Yi Zou Steffan-Dewenter, Ingolf A global synthesis reveals biodiversity-mediated benefits for crop production |
description |
Natural and modified ecosystems contribute a multitude of functions and services that support human well-being (1, 2). It has long been recognized that biodiversity plays an important role in the functioning of ecosystems (3, 4), but the dependence of ecosystem services on biodiversity is under debate. An early synthesis revealed inconsistent results
(5), whereas subsequent studies suggest that a few dominant species may supply the majority of ecosystem services (6, 7). It thus remains unclear whether a few dominant or many complementary species are needed to supply ecosystem services. The interpretation of earlier studies has been controversial because multiple mechanisms underlying changes in ecosystem service response to biodiversity can operate in combination (8, 9). On one hand, communities with many species are likely to include species responsible for large community-wide effects due to statistical selection. On the other hand, such diverse communities may contain a particular combination of species that complement each other in service provisioning. While these mechanisms imply positive effects of species richness on ecosystem service supply, total organism abundance or dominance of certain species may also drive the number of interactions benefiting ecosystem service supply. Depending on the relative importance of species complementarity, community abundance, and the role of dominant species, different relationships between species richness and ecosystem services can be expected (10). In real-world ecosystems, natural communities consist of a few highly abundant (dominant species) and many rare ones. The importance of richness, abundance, and dominance is likely to be influenced by the extent to which relative abundance changes with species richness (11) and by differences in the effectiveness and degree of specialization of service-providing communities. However, these three aspects of diversity have typically been tested in isolation and mainly in small-scale experimental settings (12, 13), while a synthetic study contrasting their SCIENCE ADVANCES | RESEARCH ARTICLE Dainese et al., Sci. Adv. 2019;5: eaax0121 16 October 2019 1 of 13 on October 17, 2019 http://advances.sciencemag.org/ Downloaded from
relative importance in real-world ecosystems is still lacking. A major limitation to resolving these relationships is a lack of evidence from real-world human-driven biodiversity changes (14, 15), particularly for ecosystem services in agroecosystems. For instance, changes in richness and total or relative abundance of service-providing organisms in
response to land-clearing for agriculture (16, 17) could alter the flow of benefits to people in different ways compared to experimental random
loss of biodiversity.
Over the past half-century, the need to feed a growing world population has led to markedly expanded and intensified agricultural production, transforming many regions into simplified landscapes (18). This transformation not only has contributed to enhanced agricultural production but also has led to the degradation of the global
environment. The loss of biodiversity can disrupt key intermediate services to agriculture, such as crop pollination (19) and biological pest control (20), which underpin the final provisioning service of crop production (21). The recent stagnation or even decline of crop yields with ongoing intensification (22) indicates that alternative pathways
are necessary to maintain future stable and sustainable crop production (23–25). An improved understanding of global biodiversity-driven ecosystem services in agroecosystems and their cascading effects on crop production is urgently needed to forecast future supplies of ecosystem services and to pursue strategies for sustainable management (15).
We compiled an extensive database comprising 89 studies that measured richness and abundance of pollinators, pest natural enemies, and associated ecosystem services at 1475 sampling locations around the world (Fig. 1A). We focused on the ecosystem services of pollination and biological pest control because these services are essential to crop production and have been the focus of much research in recent decades (26). We quantified pollinator and pest natural enemy richness as the number
of unique taxa sampledfrom each location (field), abundance as the number of observed individuals, and evenness (or the complementary term |
format |
Journal Article |
topic_facet |
crop production |
author |
Dainese, Matteo Martin, Emily A. Aizen, Marcelo A. Albrecht, Matthias Bartomeus, Ignasi Bommarco, Riccardo Carvalheiro, Luísa G. Chaplin-Kramer, Rebecca Gagic, Vesna Garibaldi, Lucas A. Ghazoul, Jaboury Grab, Heather Jonsson, Mattias Karp, Daniel S. Kennedy, Christina M. Kleijn, David Kremen, Claire Lands, Douglas A. Letourneau, Deborah K. Marini, Lorenzo Poveda, Katja Rader, Romina Smith, Henrik G. Tscharntke, Teja Andersson, Georg K.S. Badenhausser, Isabelle Baensch, Svenja Bezerra, Antonio Diego M. Bianchi, Felix J.J.A. Boreux, Virginie Bretagnolle, Vincent Caballero López, Berta Cavigliasso, Pablo Ćetković, Aleksandar Chacoff, Natacha P. Classen, Alice Cusser, Sarah Silva e Silva, Felipe D. da Groot, G. Arjen de Dudenhöffer, Jan H. Ekroos, Johan Fijen, Thijs Franck, Pierre Freitas, Breno M. Garratt, Michael P.D. Gratton, Claudio Hipólito, Juliana Holzschuh, Andrea Hunt, Lauren Iverson, Aaron L. Jha, Shalene Keasar, Tamar Kim, Tania N. Kishinevsky, Miriam Klatt, Björn K. Klein, Alexandra-Maria Krewenka, Kristin M. Krishnan, Smitha Larsen, Ashley E. Lavigne, Claire Liere, Heidi Maas, Bea Mallinger, Rachel E. Martínez Pachon, Eliana Martínez Salinas, Alejandra Meehan, Timothy D. Mitchell, Matthew G.E. Molina, Gonzalo A.R. Nesper, Maike Nilsson, Lovisa O'Rourke, Megan E. Peters, Marcell K. Plećaš, Milan Potts, Simon G. Ramos, Davi de L. Rosenheim, Jay A. Rundlöf, Maj Rusch, Adrien Sáez, Agustín Scheper, Jeroen Schleuning, Matthias Schmack, Julia M. Sciligo, Amber R. Seymour, Colleen Stanley, Dara A. Stewart, Rebecca Stout, Jane C. Sutter, Louis Takada, Mayura B. Taki, Hisatomo Tamburini, Giovanni Tschumi, Matthias Viana, Blandina F. Westphal, Catrin Willcox, Bryony K. Wratten, Stephen D. Yoshioka, Akira Zaragoza-Trello, Carlos Wei Zhang Yi Zou Steffan-Dewenter, Ingolf |
author_facet |
Dainese, Matteo Martin, Emily A. Aizen, Marcelo A. Albrecht, Matthias Bartomeus, Ignasi Bommarco, Riccardo Carvalheiro, Luísa G. Chaplin-Kramer, Rebecca Gagic, Vesna Garibaldi, Lucas A. Ghazoul, Jaboury Grab, Heather Jonsson, Mattias Karp, Daniel S. Kennedy, Christina M. Kleijn, David Kremen, Claire Lands, Douglas A. Letourneau, Deborah K. Marini, Lorenzo Poveda, Katja Rader, Romina Smith, Henrik G. Tscharntke, Teja Andersson, Georg K.S. Badenhausser, Isabelle Baensch, Svenja Bezerra, Antonio Diego M. Bianchi, Felix J.J.A. Boreux, Virginie Bretagnolle, Vincent Caballero López, Berta Cavigliasso, Pablo Ćetković, Aleksandar Chacoff, Natacha P. Classen, Alice Cusser, Sarah Silva e Silva, Felipe D. da Groot, G. Arjen de Dudenhöffer, Jan H. Ekroos, Johan Fijen, Thijs Franck, Pierre Freitas, Breno M. Garratt, Michael P.D. Gratton, Claudio Hipólito, Juliana Holzschuh, Andrea Hunt, Lauren Iverson, Aaron L. Jha, Shalene Keasar, Tamar Kim, Tania N. Kishinevsky, Miriam Klatt, Björn K. Klein, Alexandra-Maria Krewenka, Kristin M. Krishnan, Smitha Larsen, Ashley E. Lavigne, Claire Liere, Heidi Maas, Bea Mallinger, Rachel E. Martínez Pachon, Eliana Martínez Salinas, Alejandra Meehan, Timothy D. Mitchell, Matthew G.E. Molina, Gonzalo A.R. Nesper, Maike Nilsson, Lovisa O'Rourke, Megan E. Peters, Marcell K. Plećaš, Milan Potts, Simon G. Ramos, Davi de L. Rosenheim, Jay A. Rundlöf, Maj Rusch, Adrien Sáez, Agustín Scheper, Jeroen Schleuning, Matthias Schmack, Julia M. Sciligo, Amber R. Seymour, Colleen Stanley, Dara A. Stewart, Rebecca Stout, Jane C. Sutter, Louis Takada, Mayura B. Taki, Hisatomo Tamburini, Giovanni Tschumi, Matthias Viana, Blandina F. Westphal, Catrin Willcox, Bryony K. Wratten, Stephen D. Yoshioka, Akira Zaragoza-Trello, Carlos Wei Zhang Yi Zou Steffan-Dewenter, Ingolf |
author_sort |
Dainese, Matteo |
title |
A global synthesis reveals biodiversity-mediated benefits for crop production |
title_short |
A global synthesis reveals biodiversity-mediated benefits for crop production |
title_full |
A global synthesis reveals biodiversity-mediated benefits for crop production |
title_fullStr |
A global synthesis reveals biodiversity-mediated benefits for crop production |
title_full_unstemmed |
A global synthesis reveals biodiversity-mediated benefits for crop production |
title_sort |
global synthesis reveals biodiversity-mediated benefits for crop production |
publisher |
American Association for the Advancement of Science |
publishDate |
2019-10-04 |
url |
https://hdl.handle.net/10568/105463 https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aax0121 |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT dainesematteo aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT martinemilya aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT aizenmarceloa aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT albrechtmatthias aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT bartomeusignasi aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT bommarcoriccardo aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT carvalheiroluisag aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT chaplinkramerrebecca aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT gagicvesna aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT garibaldilucasa aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT ghazouljaboury aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT grabheather aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT jonssonmattias aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT karpdaniels aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kennedychristinam aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kleijndavid aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kremenclaire aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT landsdouglasa aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT letourneaudeborahk aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT marinilorenzo aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT povedakatja aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT raderromina aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT smithhenrikg aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT tscharntketeja aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT anderssongeorgks aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT badenhausserisabelle aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT baenschsvenja aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT bezerraantoniodiegom aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT bianchifelixjja aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT boreuxvirginie aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT bretagnollevincent aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT caballerolopezberta aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT cavigliassopablo aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT cetkovicaleksandar aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT chacoffnatachap aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT classenalice aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT cussersarah aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT silvaesilvafelipedda aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT grootgarjende aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT dudenhofferjanh aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT ekroosjohan aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT fijenthijs aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT franckpierre aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT freitasbrenom aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT garrattmichaelpd aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT grattonclaudio aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT hipolitojuliana aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT holzschuhandrea aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT huntlauren aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT iversonaaronl aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT jhashalene aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT keasartamar aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kimtanian aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kishinevskymiriam aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT klattbjornk aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kleinalexandramaria aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT krewenkakristinm aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT krishnansmitha aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT larsenashleye aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT lavigneclaire aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT liereheidi aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT maasbea aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT mallingerrachele aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT martinezpachoneliana aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT martinezsalinasalejandra aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT meehantimothyd aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT mitchellmatthewge aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT molinagonzaloar aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT nespermaike aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT nilssonlovisa aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT orourkemegane aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT petersmarcellk aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT plecasmilan aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT pottssimong aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT ramosdavidel aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT rosenheimjaya aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT rundlofmaj aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT ruschadrien aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT saezagustin aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT scheperjeroen aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT schleuningmatthias aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT schmackjuliam aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT sciligoamberr aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT seymourcolleen aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT stanleydaraa aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT stewartrebecca aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT stoutjanec aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT sutterlouis aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT takadamayurab aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT takihisatomo aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT tamburinigiovanni aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT tschumimatthias aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT vianablandinaf aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT westphalcatrin aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT willcoxbryonyk aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT wrattenstephend aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT yoshiokaakira aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT zaragozatrellocarlos aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT weizhang aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT yizou aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT steffandewenteringolf aglobalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT dainesematteo globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT martinemilya globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT aizenmarceloa globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT albrechtmatthias globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT bartomeusignasi globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT bommarcoriccardo globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT carvalheiroluisag globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT chaplinkramerrebecca globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT gagicvesna globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT garibaldilucasa globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT ghazouljaboury globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT grabheather globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT jonssonmattias globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT karpdaniels globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kennedychristinam globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kleijndavid globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kremenclaire globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT landsdouglasa globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT letourneaudeborahk globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT marinilorenzo globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT povedakatja globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT raderromina globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT smithhenrikg globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT tscharntketeja globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT anderssongeorgks globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT badenhausserisabelle globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT baenschsvenja globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT bezerraantoniodiegom globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT bianchifelixjja globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT boreuxvirginie globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT bretagnollevincent globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT caballerolopezberta globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT cavigliassopablo globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT cetkovicaleksandar globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT chacoffnatachap globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT classenalice globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT cussersarah globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT silvaesilvafelipedda globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT grootgarjende globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT dudenhofferjanh globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT ekroosjohan globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT fijenthijs globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT franckpierre globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT freitasbrenom globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT garrattmichaelpd globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT grattonclaudio globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT hipolitojuliana globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT holzschuhandrea globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT huntlauren globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT iversonaaronl globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT jhashalene globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT keasartamar globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kimtanian globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kishinevskymiriam globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT klattbjornk globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT kleinalexandramaria globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT krewenkakristinm globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT krishnansmitha globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT larsenashleye globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT lavigneclaire globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT liereheidi globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT maasbea globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT mallingerrachele globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT martinezpachoneliana globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT martinezsalinasalejandra globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT meehantimothyd globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT mitchellmatthewge globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT molinagonzaloar globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT nespermaike globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT nilssonlovisa globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT orourkemegane globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT petersmarcellk globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT plecasmilan globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT pottssimong globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT ramosdavidel globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT rosenheimjaya globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT rundlofmaj globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT ruschadrien globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT saezagustin globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT scheperjeroen globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT schleuningmatthias globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT schmackjuliam globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT sciligoamberr globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT seymourcolleen globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT stanleydaraa globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT stewartrebecca globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT stoutjanec globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT sutterlouis globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT takadamayurab globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT takihisatomo globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT tamburinigiovanni globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT tschumimatthias globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT vianablandinaf globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT westphalcatrin globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT willcoxbryonyk globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT wrattenstephend globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT yoshiokaakira globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT zaragozatrellocarlos globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT weizhang globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT yizou globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction AT steffandewenteringolf globalsynthesisrevealsbiodiversitymediatedbenefitsforcropproduction |
_version_ |
1787229597390077952 |
spelling |
dig-cgspace-10568-1054632023-12-08T19:36:04Z A global synthesis reveals biodiversity-mediated benefits for crop production Dainese, Matteo Martin, Emily A. Aizen, Marcelo A. Albrecht, Matthias Bartomeus, Ignasi Bommarco, Riccardo Carvalheiro, Luísa G. Chaplin-Kramer, Rebecca Gagic, Vesna Garibaldi, Lucas A. Ghazoul, Jaboury Grab, Heather Jonsson, Mattias Karp, Daniel S. Kennedy, Christina M. Kleijn, David Kremen, Claire Lands, Douglas A. Letourneau, Deborah K. Marini, Lorenzo Poveda, Katja Rader, Romina Smith, Henrik G. Tscharntke, Teja Andersson, Georg K.S. Badenhausser, Isabelle Baensch, Svenja Bezerra, Antonio Diego M. Bianchi, Felix J.J.A. Boreux, Virginie Bretagnolle, Vincent Caballero López, Berta Cavigliasso, Pablo Ćetković, Aleksandar Chacoff, Natacha P. Classen, Alice Cusser, Sarah Silva e Silva, Felipe D. da Groot, G. Arjen de Dudenhöffer, Jan H. Ekroos, Johan Fijen, Thijs Franck, Pierre Freitas, Breno M. Garratt, Michael P.D. Gratton, Claudio Hipólito, Juliana Holzschuh, Andrea Hunt, Lauren Iverson, Aaron L. Jha, Shalene Keasar, Tamar Kim, Tania N. Kishinevsky, Miriam Klatt, Björn K. Klein, Alexandra-Maria Krewenka, Kristin M. Krishnan, Smitha Larsen, Ashley E. Lavigne, Claire Liere, Heidi Maas, Bea Mallinger, Rachel E. Martínez Pachon, Eliana Martínez Salinas, Alejandra Meehan, Timothy D. Mitchell, Matthew G.E. Molina, Gonzalo A.R. Nesper, Maike Nilsson, Lovisa O'Rourke, Megan E. Peters, Marcell K. Plećaš, Milan Potts, Simon G. Ramos, Davi de L. Rosenheim, Jay A. Rundlöf, Maj Rusch, Adrien Sáez, Agustín Scheper, Jeroen Schleuning, Matthias Schmack, Julia M. Sciligo, Amber R. Seymour, Colleen Stanley, Dara A. Stewart, Rebecca Stout, Jane C. Sutter, Louis Takada, Mayura B. Taki, Hisatomo Tamburini, Giovanni Tschumi, Matthias Viana, Blandina F. Westphal, Catrin Willcox, Bryony K. Wratten, Stephen D. Yoshioka, Akira Zaragoza-Trello, Carlos Wei Zhang Yi Zou Steffan-Dewenter, Ingolf crop production Natural and modified ecosystems contribute a multitude of functions and services that support human well-being (1, 2). It has long been recognized that biodiversity plays an important role in the functioning of ecosystems (3, 4), but the dependence of ecosystem services on biodiversity is under debate. An early synthesis revealed inconsistent results (5), whereas subsequent studies suggest that a few dominant species may supply the majority of ecosystem services (6, 7). It thus remains unclear whether a few dominant or many complementary species are needed to supply ecosystem services. The interpretation of earlier studies has been controversial because multiple mechanisms underlying changes in ecosystem service response to biodiversity can operate in combination (8, 9). On one hand, communities with many species are likely to include species responsible for large community-wide effects due to statistical selection. On the other hand, such diverse communities may contain a particular combination of species that complement each other in service provisioning. While these mechanisms imply positive effects of species richness on ecosystem service supply, total organism abundance or dominance of certain species may also drive the number of interactions benefiting ecosystem service supply. Depending on the relative importance of species complementarity, community abundance, and the role of dominant species, different relationships between species richness and ecosystem services can be expected (10). In real-world ecosystems, natural communities consist of a few highly abundant (dominant species) and many rare ones. The importance of richness, abundance, and dominance is likely to be influenced by the extent to which relative abundance changes with species richness (11) and by differences in the effectiveness and degree of specialization of service-providing communities. However, these three aspects of diversity have typically been tested in isolation and mainly in small-scale experimental settings (12, 13), while a synthetic study contrasting their SCIENCE ADVANCES | RESEARCH ARTICLE Dainese et al., Sci. Adv. 2019;5: eaax0121 16 October 2019 1 of 13 on October 17, 2019 http://advances.sciencemag.org/ Downloaded from relative importance in real-world ecosystems is still lacking. A major limitation to resolving these relationships is a lack of evidence from real-world human-driven biodiversity changes (14, 15), particularly for ecosystem services in agroecosystems. For instance, changes in richness and total or relative abundance of service-providing organisms in response to land-clearing for agriculture (16, 17) could alter the flow of benefits to people in different ways compared to experimental random loss of biodiversity. Over the past half-century, the need to feed a growing world population has led to markedly expanded and intensified agricultural production, transforming many regions into simplified landscapes (18). This transformation not only has contributed to enhanced agricultural production but also has led to the degradation of the global environment. The loss of biodiversity can disrupt key intermediate services to agriculture, such as crop pollination (19) and biological pest control (20), which underpin the final provisioning service of crop production (21). The recent stagnation or even decline of crop yields with ongoing intensification (22) indicates that alternative pathways are necessary to maintain future stable and sustainable crop production (23–25). An improved understanding of global biodiversity-driven ecosystem services in agroecosystems and their cascading effects on crop production is urgently needed to forecast future supplies of ecosystem services and to pursue strategies for sustainable management (15). We compiled an extensive database comprising 89 studies that measured richness and abundance of pollinators, pest natural enemies, and associated ecosystem services at 1475 sampling locations around the world (Fig. 1A). We focused on the ecosystem services of pollination and biological pest control because these services are essential to crop production and have been the focus of much research in recent decades (26). We quantified pollinator and pest natural enemy richness as the number of unique taxa sampledfrom each location (field), abundance as the number of observed individuals, and evenness (or the complementary term 2019-10-04 2019-10-18T04:39:28Z 2019-10-18T04:39:28Z Journal Article Dainese, M. et al. 2019. A global synthesis reveals biodiversity-mediated benefits for crop production. ScienceAdvances 5(10). 2375-2548 https://hdl.handle.net/10568/105463 https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aax0121 Enhancing Sustainability Across Agricultural Systems en CC-BY-NC-4.0 Open Access application/pdf American Association for the Advancement of Science |